Cape May Olive Oil Company

Where Is It? On Carpenter’s Lane, tucked behind the mall.

Why Should I Go? For their 25th anniversary, Carl and Susan Spatocco traveled to Napa Valley. While there, they sampled olive oils and spreads, which they enjoyed so much that plenty were brought home. Inspired by these savory souvenirs, the couple decided to open up a shop of their own, where others could enjoy gourmet food products as well.

Here, you will experience a wide variety of flavorful olive oils, including Butter, Chipotle, and Black Truffle. Despite the name, Cape May Olive Oil sells much more than just olive oil — they also offer balsamic vinegars, dips and spreads, including a line of tapenades.

Insider Tip: Visit sister stores, Spice Cellar, Cape May Peanut Butter Company, the Cheese Shop and Wingnutz.

Website: capemayoliveoilcompany.com

Phone: 609-898-4441

Address: 324 Carpenter’s Lane, Cape May