Cape May Peanut Butter Company

Where Is It? On Carpenter’s Lane, right off the Washington Street Mall.

Why Should I Go? There is a reason their sign reads “The Happiest Place in Cape May.” The smell of fresh-baked cookies engulfs your senses right when you walk through the door. Their friendly, knowledgeable staff greets you with samples of tasty treats and a willingness to help you choose your favorites. Enjoy those treats in the courtyard out back where pets and children are welcome!

Amongst all that, you can’t forget the peanut butter. This is not your average supermarket peanut butter. All ingredients are of the highest quality, the texture is unique and the flavors just POP! Almond, chocolate, butterscotch, cappuccino, sunflower... the list goes on — you’ll just have to try them all.

Insider Tip: Cape May Olive Oil Company, Spice Cellar and the Cheese Shop are within walking distance. Now THAT is sweet.

Website: capemaypeanutbutterco.com

Phone: 609-898-4444

Address: 516 Carpenter’s Lane, Cape May