Oyster Bay Steak & Seafood House

Where Is It? On Lafayette Street, opposite the Acme.

Why Should I Go? Oyster Bay is one of those restaurants you know is going to be good, even before you take a bite or read a review. Here are some of the signs...

1. It’s not the kind of place that snags you with a waterfront view. And it’s not inside one of the restored mansions or B&Bs that draw tourists with their history. It’s just a simple building, a little off the beaten path. And it’s STILL busy.

2. Oyster Bay attracts locals as well as tourists, which is always a good sign.

3. Chef Chris Holl is also the owner, meaning he cares that much more. The meat/seafood combos are varied, so you can try something new, even when ordering an old favorite. Filet mignon topped with jumbo lump crab meat anyone?

4. There’s a stunning, 28-seat cherry wood bar, with a bar menu. A fun, buzzy alternative to the main dining room.

Insider Tip: The menu changes seasonally — given that Oyster Bay is open 10 months of the year, that gives you plenty of opportunities to sample the goods!

Website: oysterbayrestaurant.com

Phone: 609-884-2111

Address: 615 Lafayette Street, Cape May